This tintype was in the possession of Lucinda Keithley Mourning's descendants. There were no names on the back of the picture, but Jacob and Sarah were identified from another set of pictures taken of them 10 to 15 years later. Since it's easier to date a picture once the youngest child is known, focus was put on the boy on the right. Jacob and Sarah's youngest child was Joseph, born February 15, 1845. This boy looked to be between eleven and fourteen-years-old. The boy on the left looked to be between four and six years older than the boy on the right. In the family tree, Joseph and Perry were four years apart and still living at home, so the two boys had to be Perry & Joseph. The woman in the middle was much harder to identify. At first, it was thought that it might be Perry's wife, but Perry was married in 1865, and Joseph would've been twenty-years-old, too old for this picture. Still unsure what year the picture was taken, from Joseph's approximate age, it was felt that it had to be between 1857 and 1860. Since the tintype came down from Lucinda's descendants, it was thought that she might be the woman in the middle, but as can be seen by comparing a picture of Lucinda to this woman, it's not, because the shape of Lucinda's face isn't the same as the woman in the picture. She could've been a daughter-in-law of Jacob and Sarah's, but their eldest child was Mary Jane Keithley Hainline, and this woman's face is shaped more like Jacob's face in the other picture. A closer look at the woman shows that she's pregnant. She's standing a little to the side and her hand is on her stomach. The angle of how she's standing and where her hand is placed indicates that she's eight or nine months pregnant. Taking Joseph's age into account, Mary Jane had to be pregnant with Seth, who was born September 1, 1858, which would mean that it was taken sometime in August, 1858. The picture was probably taken in Macomb. It's possible that a travelling photographer took the picture at their home. It's unknown if there were that many travelling photographers at that period of time, so it's more likely that they went to Macomb to have it taken. It's understandable that Jacob and Sarah would have a picture taken with Perry and Joseph, but how Mary Jane ended up in it is unknown. She had eight children at that time, so either they were being taken care of by someone else so she could go to Macomb, or the picture was taken at Jacob & Sarah's home. Sarah might've been helping with the children while Mary Jane was pregnant, or maybe Mary Jane was devoted to her mother and spent time taking care of her parents. It's hoped that another picture of her will be found to compare to this picture and verify that she's the woman in the middle. She lived to 1892, and pictures were probably taken of her. Notice the hat-hair on Jacob and the two boys.